Court Upholds Rejection of 21 Talathi Recruitment Candidates Amid Cyber Fraud Allegations

Nagpur: In a significant ruling with implications for future online recruitment examinations, the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal (MAT), Aurangabad Bench, has upheld the Maharashtra government’s decision to withhold the results of 21 candidates in the Talathi Recruitment Examination 2023, citing suspicious digital patterns detected in TCS audit log reports.

Follow MahaENews-X on: Follow MahaENews on Instagram

The tribunal dismissed the petitions filed by the candidates, observing that digital evidence such as audit logs can be more reliable than CCTV footage in detecting irregularities during computer-based examinations.

Suspicious Digital Patterns Found

Referring to the TCS audit log report, the tribunal highlighted several unusual patterns recorded during the examination:

Some candidates viewed all 100 questions within the first few minutes without attempting any answers.

They remained inactive for a considerable period during the examination.

A large number of answers were submitted or changed rapidly during the last 30–40 minutes of the exam.

Candidates frequently switched between different sections of the question paper and repeatedly navigated to specific questions using the number panel.

The tribunal observed that these digital activities were highly suspicious and warranted administrative action.

CCTV Argument Rejected

The candidates argued that CCTV footage showed no evidence of malpractice, claiming they had solved questions on rough sheets before entering answers into the computer.

However, the tribunal rejected this defence, stating that cyber-enabled malpractice may not be visible through CCTV surveillance, and that digital records such as audit logs provide more accurate evidence of candidate activity during online examinations.

The tribunal further noted that the sudden changes in answer patterns recorded in the audit logs could not be satisfactorily explained by the candidates’ arguments.

No Automatic Right to Appointment

The tribunal clarified that selection in the merit list does not automatically guarantee appointment. Appointment can only be granted after successful completion of all verification procedures.

It also emphasized that maintaining fairness, transparency, and credibility in the recruitment process is the responsibility of the administration.

Directions for Further Investigation

The tribunal directed the Maharashtra government to:

Conduct a detailed forensic investigation into the alleged cyber malpractice.

Identify the individuals or organised groups involved.

Initiate appropriate legal action under relevant cybercrime laws.

Impact on Future Online Examinations

The ruling is expected to strengthen the importance of digital forensic evidence, particularly audit logs, in investigations involving computer-based competitive examinations.

The decision also comes at a time when the Maharashtra Public Service Commission (MPSC) is preparing to conduct preliminary examinations in an online mode, making the judgment particularly significant for future recruitment processes.

Demand for SIT Probe

Reacting to the decision, Rahul Kavathekar, representing the Competitive Examination Coordination Committee, Maharashtra, alleged that the Talathi recruitment case is the country’s biggest examination scam after the NEET controversy.

He demanded that the Maharashtra government constitute a Special Investigation Team (SIT) headed by a retired High Court judge to conduct an impartial and comprehensive investigation into the alleged recruitment scam and examine the transparency of various government recruitment examinations conducted through TCS.

Follow MahaENews-X on: Follow MahaENews on Instagram